Bridging Gaps in Mental Health: Evaluating the Mental Healthcare Act, 2017

ABSTRACT

Mental health has emerged as a critical area of concern in public health discourse globally and in India. The enactment of the Mental Healthcare Act, 2017, marks a significant milestone in the legal framework addressing mental health issues in India. This paper, titled "Bridging Gaps in Mental Health: Evaluating the Mental Healthcare Act, 2017," undertakes a comprehensive evaluation of the Act, exploring its positive contributions, inherent limitations, and the challenges faced during its implementation. The Mental Healthcare Act, 2017, represents a paradigm shift from the custodial approach to a rights-based framework. It seeks to empower persons with mental illness by recognizing their rights to access mental healthcare, make treatment decisions, and receive protection from inhumane treatment. The Act mandates the establishment of mental health authorities at the central and state levels to oversee its implementation and ensure the availability of mental health services. One of the most commendable provisions is the right to make an advance directive, allowing individuals to express their treatment preferences during periods of mental wellness. Furthermore, the Act decriminalizes attempted suicide, acknowledging the need for compassionate intervention rather than punitive measures. Despite its progressive intent, the Mental Healthcare Act, 2017, faces several criticisms and practical implementation challenges. The paper identifies gaps in infrastructure, the shortage of qualified mental health professionals, and the lack of public awareness as major obstacles to effective enforcement. The ambitious mandate for mental health services is hindered by inadequate funding and the slow establishment of mental health review boards. Additionally, the procedural complexities surrounding the advance directive and concerns about balancing autonomy with the need for urgent medical intervention pose further challenges. The paper also addresses the lack of integration between mental health policies and the broader healthcare system, which exacerbates the difficulties in delivering comprehensive mental health services. Through an in-depth analysis, this paper emphasizes the need for a multi-stakeholder approach to bridge the existing gaps in mental healthcare delivery. Policy recommendations include increasing budgetary allocations, strengthening community-based mental health services, enhancing training programs for healthcare providers, and promoting mental health literacy among the general population. The paper argues that while the Mental Healthcare Act, 2017, is a commendable legal instrument, its success ultimately depends on sustained political commitment, inter-sectoral collaboration, and robust implementation frameworks. By shedding light on the successes and shortcomings of the Mental Healthcare Act, 2017, this paper contributes to the broader discourse on mental health governance in India. It underscores the importance of a holistic and inclusive approach to mental health policy that recognizes the dignity and rights of persons with mental illness. Bridging the gaps in mental health requires not only legal reforms but also comprehensive societal and systemic changes that prioritize mental well-being as an integral component of public health.

FULL TEXT